The main difference is where you sleep. In residential treatment, you live at the program, with staff there 24 hours a day. In a partial hospitalization program (PHP), sometimes called day treatment, you spend most of the day in treatment, usually 20 or more hours a week, and go home or to sober housing at night. Residential fits people who can't stay safe or sober outside a structured setting right now. PHP fits people who need intensive daily care but have a stable, substance-free place to live and can get there every day.
The right choice should come from a professional assessment, not just preference or price. Below is how the two compare and the questions that usually decide it.
How the levels of care are defined
Most programs and insurers use the ASAM Criteria, a set of placement standards from the American Society of Addiction Medicine. A federal Medicaid resource guide based on the ASAM Criteria describes them this way (Medicaid.gov ASAM resource guide):
- Level 2.5, partial hospitalization: programs that "provide 20 hours or more of clinically intensive programming each week." By comparison, intensive outpatient (Level 2.1) is 9 to 19 hours a week for adults.
- Level 3, residential: services "provided in a structured, residential setting that is staffed 24 hours daily."
- 3.1 is lower-intensity, with at least 5 hours of treatment a week, for people who mainly need a stable, structured place to live.
- 3.5 is for people "in some imminent danger with functional limitations who cannot safely be treated outside of a 24-hour stable living environment." This is what most people mean by "inpatient rehab."
- 3.7 is medically monitored, for people who need "highly structured 24-hour services" with medical observation.
A newer edition of the ASAM Criteria has updated some names and descriptions, so a program or insurer may use slightly different labels. Ask them to explain what their level means in hours and staffing.
Side by side
| Residential (Level 3.5 / 3.7) | PHP (Level 2.5) | |
|---|---|---|
| Where you sleep | At the program | At home or in sober living |
| Hours of treatment | All day, every day, with 24-hour staff | Most of the day, several days a week (20+ hours total) |
| Medical and nursing care | On site; more medical oversight at 3.7 | Available during program hours |
| Access to alcohol or drugs | Removed from the environment | Possible every evening and weekend |
| Work, school, family | Paused | Mostly paused during program hours |
| Typical cost | Higher (room, board and round-the-clock staff) | Lower than residential |
| Insurance | Often needs prior authorization and ongoing reviews | Also often needs prior authorization |
Hours and staffing vary by program and state, so treat the table as a general guide.
How placement is actually decided
ASAM-based assessments look at six areas, or "dimensions" (College of DuPage, Addictions Counseling text):
- Withdrawal risk. Could you go into dangerous withdrawal?
- Physical health. Are there medical problems that need watching?
- Mental health. Depression, anxiety, trauma, thoughts of suicide?
- Readiness to change.
- Relapse risk. How likely is use in the next days or weeks without support?
- Recovery environment. Is home safe, stable and free of alcohol and drugs?
The same text notes that counselors "should recommend the least restrictive effective level of care." In plain terms: the least intense option that is still likely to work and keep you safe.
Signs residential is the better fit
- Home has alcohol or drugs in it, or people who use
- Home is unsafe, or there is no stable place to live
- Several tries at outpatient or PHP haven't held
- Serious mental health symptoms that need watching day and night
- You'd likely use as soon as you left a day program
- You live too far from a PHP to get there every day
Signs PHP may be enough
- You've finished detox or don't need one, and are medically stable
- You have a safe, sober place to sleep (home, family or sober living)
- You have dependable transportation
- You need more than weekly therapy but not 24-hour supervision
- You're stepping down from residential and want to practice life at home with support
Many people do both: a few weeks of residential, then PHP, then intensive outpatient. Ask any program how it handles step-down and whether it can move you to a different level without a gap.
If withdrawal is a risk, detox comes first. Alcohol and benzodiazepine withdrawal can be dangerous and need medical supervision, and neither residential nor PHP should be used as a substitute for medical detox when it's needed.
Questions to ask before you choose
- What level of care do you think I need, and why?
- How many hours a day is your PHP, and how many days a week?
- For residential: is a nurse or doctor on site, and at what hours?
- Do you treat mental health conditions alongside addiction?
- Do you offer medication for opioid or alcohol use disorder, or work with a prescriber who does?
- Is my insurance in network, and does it need prior authorization for this level?
- What happens when insurance stops approving days?
- What does step-down look like after this level?
Our guides to questions to ask a rehab before you go and what "in network" means for rehab cover these in more detail.
Finding both options near you
This site compares 8,587 licensed treatment centers in 15 states, using SAMHSA data. Of those, 1,717 list residential treatment, 1,535 list partial hospitalization, and 344 offer both, which can make step-down easier. Start from the state list or a city page like Phoenix or Boston, where each listing shows its levels of care and the insurance it accepts.
Getting help
If you're not sure which level fits, a short conversation can help sort it out. Call (844) 722-4245 to talk with an admissions counselor at TOS. You can also call the free, confidential SAMHSA National Helpline at 1-800-662-4357 to find local programs, including ones that take Medicaid or offer sliding-scale fees. If you or someone you love is in crisis, call or text 988.